Fisher Island
Fisher Island is a condominium in Fisher Island. Residences range from $11M to $11.9M.
Amenities
- Basketball Court
- Bike Storage
- Bike/Jog Path
- Golf Equity Available
- Marina
- Pool
- Private Pool
- Billiard Room
- Boat Dock
- Clubhouse
- Community Room
- Courtesy Bus
- Elevator(s)
- Exercise Room
- Exterior Lighting
- Security Patrol
- Spa/Hot Tub
- Storage
- Tennis Court(s)
- Trash Chute
Income
Employment
Income Brackets (%)
Population
Age Distribution (%)
Housing Tenure
Ownership (%)
Education (age 25+)
Educational Attainment (%)
Commute to Work
How Residents Commute (%)
Population
Race & Ethnicity (%)
Fisher Island, FL 33109
Available Residences at Fisher Island
4 Bedroom Condos · 2 units
| Unit | Asking Price | Bed(s)/Bath(s) | Living Size | Price/Sq.Ft. | Days on Market |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| — | $11,900,000 | 4 / 5 / 1 | 4,109 | $2,896 | 418 |
| 5134 | $10,980,000 | 4 / 5 / 1 | 4,109 | $2,672 | 252 |
ANALYTICS
CURRENT INVENTORY
INVENTORY BY BEDROOM
- 4 Bed (2) 100%
INVENTORY TREND (ALL UNITS)
Market & Community Report
As of August 18, 2026, Fisher Island carries 2 active listings at an average asking price of $11.4M, with an average time on market of 335 days. Closed sales over the preceding 36 months averaged $2,359 per sq ft, and 0 transactions closed in the past 12 months — implying — months of supply against the current pace of absorption.
Zip code 33109 (Fisher Island) is home to 893 residents with a median age of 57.1. Per-capita income stands at $302,761; 67.5% hold a bachelor's degree or higher. 94.3% of units are owner-occupied; 80.9% of residents work from home.
Data current as of August 18, 2026. Market metrics derived from MLS closed sales; community data from U.S. Census ACS.
Frequently Asked Questions — Fisher Island
How many condos are for sale at Fisher Island?
As of August 18, 2026, 2 residences are actively listed for sale at Fisher Island. Current asking prices range from $11M to $11.9M. Inventory updates daily from the MLS.
How much do condos at Fisher Island cost?
Condos at Fisher Island are currently asking from $11M to $11.9M. Over the past 36 months, closed sales have averaged $2,359 per square foot. Final pricing varies by floor, line, square footage, finishes, and view.
What is the average price per square foot at Fisher Island?
Based on MLS closed sales over the preceding 36 months, the average sale price at Fisher Island is $2,359 per square foot. Use this as a benchmark when comparing active listings in the building.
Where is Fisher Island located?
Fisher Island is located at 5134 Fisher Island Dr, Fisher Island, FL, 33109.
What amenities does Fisher Island offer?
Fisher Island amenities include Basketball Court, Bike Storage, Bike/Jog Path, Golf Equity Available, Marina, Pool, Private Pool, Billiard Room.